Jamaica Plain Punch: Boat Drink Recipes

After one sip, you’ll be Jamaican mi crazy!

Has rum changed history? Can it change a person’s path in life? I believe “YES” is the answer to both of those questions. Today’s Boat Drink recipe comes to us from Castaway Mixologist Jeremy McDaniel, and he tell his story of how a rum cocktail might have changed American history.

“History is my job. As a high school history teacher I obviously have a love of history, which is another reason why I think I gravitate towards rum. Rum goes hand in hand with American history (you MUST read Wayne Curtis book “And a Bottle of Rum”). This cocktail is a variation of Boston Rum Punch (dark Jamaican Rum and Lemonade) which was the drink of choice in colonial Boston “fueling” feelings of independence and revolution! David Wondrich via liquor.com offered this simple yet wonderful cocktail. This is my variation.”

Jamaica Plain Punch

(Jamaica Plain is a neighborhood in Beantown)


  • 2oz – 3oz each of
  • Simply Lemonade
  • Simply Lemonade w/Mango
  • 2oz Jamaican Rum (any Appleton, Wray and Nephew, Myers, Smith and Cross, Blackwell)
  • 2-3 dashes Angostura Bitters

Mixing Instructions: Shake all with cracked ice. Strain in highball glass with ice and top with nutmeg. Raise glass and toast.

I do think rum has affected people’s lives and also world history. Rum can inspire creative thought and has lubricated the talents of many writers, painters and leaders. Rum can also take people down a less responsible road, so please drink responsibly.

Rum has obviously had a huge impact on the Caribbean ever since the first Europeans found their way here. Not all that history is pretty, but it has built the foundation for the islands that we love so much. History in a glass.


By |2016-12-31T11:58:08+00:00October 30th, 2013|Boat Drinks|2 Comments

About the Author:

Just a salty pirate looking to explore and document the wonders of the Caribbean. Professional blogger, rum judge, consultant, marketer, and consumer of blue water beauty.


  1. Jeremy McDaniel October 30, 2013 at 4:57 pm

    Making this jug size for the cabin next weekend to celebrate my 30th. Might have to rely on my “starting backcourt” Appleton V/X and Wray and Nephew! Still haven’t found a better duo in rum drinks!

  2. mm
    RumShopRyan October 30, 2013 at 5:55 pm

    Happy early birthday Jeremy! Thanks for mixing us another great boat drink. I’m with you, can’t beat that Jamaican combo…maybe Mount Gay are Fire Rum…Barbados style! Cheers!

Comments are closed.